Shop

✨ Featured Presales

Monthly Specials

Bagels

Spreads

Baked Goods

Catering

Subscriptions

Bagel Lab

Featured Presales(1)

1 item

October: Pumpkin French Toast Stuffed Bagel

Pumpkin French toast bagel stuffed with pumpkin pie cream cheese, garnished with powdered sugar and fresh fruit. Served with maple syrup.

Order Window

10/01/2026 12:00 AM - 10/29/2026 12:00 AM

Fulfillment

10/31/2026 • 2:00 PM-7:00 PM

View Details

Monthly Specials(3)

Bialy

Your choice of either caramelized onion & gruyere filled bialy or pepperoni pizza bialy.

$3.00 each

As low as $2.75 (4+)

New

October Specials: Bagels

Half dozen monthly special bagels (See variation list for flavors)

$12.00

New

Apple Spice Cream Cheese

House-made apple pie filling with fresh apples, cinnamon, nutmeg, and brown sugar swirled into house-whipped cream cheese.

$5.00

Bagels(3)

Half-Dozen Bagels

Six bagels, made fresh to order!

$13.00

Baker's Dozen Bagels

13 lucky bagels, made fresh to order! The 13th bagel will be randomly selected.

$25.00

Half-Dozen Gluten-Sensitivity Friendly Bagels

Six gluten-sensitivity friendly bagels, made fresh to order!

BagelBagel is not a certified gluten-free facility. Some gluten contamination is inevitable, as all gluten-sensitivity friendly products are made using the same equipment in the same kitchen, and all ingredients are stored in the same area. Contains wheat.

$18.00

Spreads(1)

Cream Cheese

8 oz container of house-whipped cream cheese.

Starting at $5.00

Baked Goods(3)

NY Style Cookies

Dangerously delicious, and inspired by New York bakeries, these cookies weigh in at a massive 6oz (that's more than a third of a pound!).

Current varieties include chocolate chip walnut and triple chocolate. Each cookie is thicc and decadent, packed full of gooey, semi-sweet and milk chocolate chips!

$4.00

Scones (rotating variety)

Flaky, buttery, a little savory, and a little sweet; American cream scones are the cousin of the traditional buttermilk biscuit, and can be made into a variety of flavors!

Check our social media for our weekly rotating selection!

$4.00

Baklava

Thin, flaky sheets of phyllo dough layered with pistachios, dried cranberries, cinnamon, and sugar, soaked in a rich syrup made with honey, lemon, cinnamon, hibiscus, and a touch of rose.

$5.00

Catering(4)

Bagel Platter

Dozen bagels, freshly prepared, sliced, and arranged on a platter with 16oz of cream cheese.

$37.00

Big Breakfast Box

Two-dozen bagels, freshly prepared, and sliced, 2lbs of cream cheese, and enough single-use knives and napkins to go around.

$85.00

Nova Platter

Thin-sliced nova salmon, house-pickled red onions, capers, thin sliced tomato, fresh dill, and lemon wedges. Pairs great with a bagel platter! Serves 12.

$45.00

Tea Party

Your choice of 8 mini scones, or mini bagels, select tea blend from Two Maidens, whipped butter.

Includes knives, & napkins.

$35.00

Subscriptions(1)

Best Seller

The Breakfast Club

The Breakfast Club is a subscription service for fresh bagels scheduled for pickup weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly! each order includes a customer-selected variety of bagels, plus an additional baker-selected menu item, and may include a new or future menu item!

Cream cheese is now available as an optional add-on at additional (but discounted!) cost.

Breakfast Club members also receive a 10% off coupon code to be used on any future orders!

Starting at $12.00

Bagel Lab(1)

New

Bagel Lab: London Fog

Classic sourdough bagel base infused with earl grey tea, citrus, milk & honey.

$2.50