About Baked Cakes by Lily
Hi, I’m Lily 🧁 the heart behind this little bakery of sweet creations 💕 I specialize in handcrafted cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and custom treats made to turn everyday moments into something truly special. There’s nothing I love more than bringing an idea to life in buttercream and sprinkles whether it’s a birthday surprise, a celebration centerpiece, or a simple treat just because. Every order is made with care, creativity, and a genuine love for making people smile. If you’re looking for desserts that not only taste amazing but feel personal and memorable, I’d be honored to create something sweet for you. Let’s make your next moment a little sweeter ✨
Fulfillment Methods
Mon - Sun
9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Bronx, Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens
Mon - Sun
9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Bronx, Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens
Mon - Sun
9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Payment Methods
Secured by Square
Policies
50% of total order
5 days
Customer reviews
What customers are saying
Recent notes from customers.
5 reviews
- 04/27/2026
Bake Cake by Lily truly exceeded expectations. She created a stunning Puerto Rican–themed cake for DJ Carlito, and the level of detail was incredible. Every element felt thoughtful and well-crafted, capturing the theme perfectly. You can tell she puts real passion into her work. I was genuinely impressed—not just with how it looked, but the overall quality. Highly recommend her if you want something unique and beautifully done
ObsesionfilmsCustomer Review - 04/07/2026
I ordered a tres leches cupcake from BakedCakesByLily and it was absolutely delicious! It was super moist, full of flavor, and honestly one of the best cupcakes I’ve had. You can tell it was made with care. I would definitely order again and highly recommend trying it! :)
RoseCustomer Review - 03/05/2026
My first experience with Lily’s baked goods was a catered event! She made cookies and cupcakes that were so good I just kept coming back for more! I took a bunch home and my sister even stole some from me because they were THAT good! Super moist, soft and buttery! As well as beautiful! Tonight I had some cupcakes by Lily (Vanilla, Oreo and Banana Pudding) and when I tell You they were phenomenal!!! The vanilla was super soft, the cake was moist and the icing was so light and airy. Same with the cookies and cream, light and airy but packed with flavor and not too sweet! But the true star of the show was the Banana Pudding 😍 it tasted just like I was eating banana pudding! The banana flavor was all throughout the cake itself and the icing but not overpowering at all! And there was some surprise banana crème filling inside the cupcake that just takes it over the top! Easily my favorite cupcake of hers so far!!! 😋 RUN don’t walk to BakedCakesByLily!!!! You won’t regret it!
Zairay CashCustomer Review
- Verified Order
- written by customers who ordered through this shop.
- Invited Customer
- written by customers the store invited, often for purchases made in person, by message or on another platform.
- Customer Review
- posted publicly and not matched to an order.
Reviews are shown newest first and are never filtered by rating. A review is hidden only for abuse, spam or advertising, personal details, a duplicate, or not being about this store or its customers.