Featured Products
About BucketsOfSugar
A passionate home baker based in Florida, specializing in high-quality, handmade cookies and treats. Everything is baked fresh for your order—bringing you that unforgettable homemade flavor! Homemade Cookies, Cinnamon Rolls, Mini Cakes, and more to come!
Fulfillment Methods
Front Door Pickup
Choose this option if you’re able to meet at a Publix location I select for pickup.
Mon - Sun
9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Mon - Sun
9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday
Payment Methods
CashApp - Venmo
Policies
2 days
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes! As a Florida CFO, we are legally allowed to ship our non-PHF baked goods to customers within Florida and, under certain interpretations, across state lines via the United States Postal Service or commercial mail delivery service. We package our items carefully, but are not responsible for delays or damage once the package is accepted by the carrier.
We recommend placing orders 3 days/weeks in advance for standard items. Custom cakes or large orders (when I get to that stage) require a minimum of [2] weeks notice.
You will receive a confirmation email with our pickup address and your scheduled time slot. Please arrive promptly during your window. Text or call us when you arrive, and we will bring your order out to you!
Yes! We love creating custom orders. Please submit a Custom Order Request Form [Link to Form] with as many details as possible (date, theme, desired flavors, inspiration photos) for a quote
All of our signature cookies, including the Cinnamon Toast Crunch and the Strawberry Matcha, contain at a minimum: WHEAT, EGGS, MILK, and SOY (soy lecithin is commonly found in white chocolate and baking ingredients). We must disclose all allergens in each item on the product page and on the label.
We primarily use natural colorants, such as the matcha green tea in our [Strawberry Matcha] cookie. If we use artificial food coloring for custom designs, it will be disclosed at the time of order.