Frosted by Shelby

Make your milestone moment truly unforgettable. Baked to golden perfection, our custom letter and number cookie cakes offer the ultimate alternative to traditional sheet cakes. Each design features two delicate, stacked cookie layers filled and topped with gorgeous piped buttercream rosettes, custom color palettes, and playful sprinkles or accents. Whether celebrating a 1st birthday, an anniversary, or a graduation, these personalized showstoppers look just as incredible as they taste.

Please select your customizations and request a quote today! I will review what you submitted to determine the work necessary for your custom cookie cake and get back with you timely with a final total!

Perfect for grazing tables, dessert platters, and effortless snacking, these mini treats pack full-sized flavor into a single bite. Each 1.5-inch cookie bite features a golden, tender center and is topped with a signature swirl of crusting buttercream piped to match your event's custom color palette.

• ​Best For: Corporate mixers, wedding dessert bars, birthday grazing boards, or school celebrations.
• ​Perks: Easy to mix and match flavors, no forks or plates required, and sized perfectly for guests who want to sample a little of everything.

Every batch is baked fresh to order and customized to your theme. Select your cookie base, choose your frosting colors, and let us handle the details—from simple, elegant rosettes to playful, vibrant textures.

MINIMUM ORDER: 2 DOZEN

Easy to serve and impossible to resist, our Single‑Layer Pre‑Cut Cookie Tray is designed for effortless sharing. Each tray features a soft cookie base topped with smooth buttercream frosting, then pre‑cut into clean, ready‑to‑grab squares. No knives, no mess — just simple, sweet enjoyment.

Perfect for classrooms, birthday parties, potlucks, or any event where convenience meets deliciousness. Every bite is soft, sweet, and beautifully frosted.

Please select your customizations and request a quote today! I will review what you submitted to determine the work necessary for your custom cookie cake and get back with you timely with a final total!

Bring your unique party vision to life with a Custom Cookie Cake! Whether you have a specific color palette, a party theme, or an inspiration photo in mind, this cookie is fully customized for your celebration. We use our signature vanilla or chocolate icing to color-match your theme perfectly, finished off with a personalized message and your choice of toppings. Because these edible works of art take a little extra magic, please plan ahead!

Please select your customizations and request a quote today! I will review what you submitted to determine the work necessary for your custom cookie cake and get back with you timely with a final total!

Need a delicious centerpiece in a pinch? Our Classic Cookie Cake is designed for a quick turnaround without sacrificing flavor or fun. Baked to chewy perfection, this single layer cookie cake is piped with your choice of our classic vanilla or rich chocolate icing (kept natural with no color added) and topped with rainbow sprinkles. Ready within a 2 day tunraround.

Nostalgia in every bite! We’ve taken a childhood favorite and given it the ultimate home-bakery upgrade. Each order comes with a 6-pack of soft, perfectly spiced 2-inch oatmeal cookies, sandwiched around a generous layer of our fluffy, signature vanilla icing. They are chewy, sweet, and strictly better than the ones you remember from the grocery store.

A cherished family recipe, baked into the perfect bite-sized treat! We took our classic, generations-old family banana bread recipe and added a special twist to make it uniquely our own. These mini muffins are incredibly moist, packed with sweet banana flavor, and perfect for a quick breakfast, lunchbox addition, or afternoon pick-me-up. Sold by the dozen.

When you want a cookie that makes a statement, our oversized 3.5" Drop Cookies deliver. These bakery‑style cookies are thick, indulgent, and perfect for sharing — though you may not want to. Available in all your favorite flavors, like Chocolate Chip, Sugar, Snickerdoodle, Peanut Butter, Oatmeal, and Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, each cookie is crafted for maximum softness and richness. Pair them with optional frosting cups for the ultimate treat.

Soft, chewy, and baked fresh to golden perfection, our Classic Drop Cookies are the classic treat everyone reaches for first. Choose from nostalgic favorites like Chocolate Chip, Sugar, Snickerdoodle, Peanut Butter, Oatmeal, and Oatmeal Chocolate Chip. Each cookie is sized at 1.5", bursting with flavor, and made to order. Add frosting cups for dipping to take your cookie experience to the next level.