Skip to content

New flavor "Double Trouble" releasing 10/11

Shop

Cookies
Bread
Gifts

Cookies(8)

Build-a-Bat Box

Why choose just one flavor?


Build your own half-dozen, 8-pack, or dozen with any flavor combination of Sugarbat favorites! Mix, match, and fill your box with exactly what you're craving (while still getting a deal!)


Go all-in on your favorites or summon a little bit of everything!

$18.00

Seasonal

S'morcery Cookie

A little campfire magic, conjured Sugarbat-style. Our signature brown butter cookie dough is loaded with semi-sweet chocolate chunks and dark chocolate chips, wrapped around a gooey marshmallow center, then baked right on top of a butter-dipped graham cracker.


The result? Crispy edges, melty chocolate, toasted marshmallow, and that classic graham cracker crunch in every decadent bite. Consider it s’mores... with a little dark magic from the Graham Reaper!💀🔥

$3.50

Boneyard Cookie

Sweet, salty, and almost too much.


In Collaboration with Jimmy Bones of Bones Beard & Body:

Our signature brown butter cookie dough is loaded with creamy white chocolate, rich butterscotch chips, crunchy English toffee, and salty pretzel pieces, then finished with a sprinkle of flaky sea salt. Every bite is buttery, gooey, crunchy, and dangerously addictive, the perfect place to bury your self-control.

$3.50

Seasonal

The Parent Trap - Double Trouble

Rich browned-butter cookie dough packed with Double Stuf Oreo pieces wraps around a generous center of sweet, velvety peanut butter filling.

Buttery, chocolatey, and full of cookies-and-cream goodness: it’s the iconic movie snack baked into one irresistible cookie.


Created in collaboration with Front Porch Flour Co., this nostalgic treat brings a little Annie-and-Hallie magic to every bite. No secret handshake required. 👯‍♀️

$3.50

Best Seller

Bat Chip Crazy Cookie

An indulgent browned-butter cookie dough loaded with dark chocolate chunks, semi-sweet morsels, and mini semi-sweet chocolate chips, finished with a touch of flaky sea salt.

$3.50

Ghoul's Gold Cookie

Rich browned-butter cookie dough packed with roasted macadamias and luscious white chocolate, with delicate caramel notes throughout.

$3.50

Peanut Batty Cookie

Now bigger & better!


An ultra-soft, deeply peanut-buttery cookie made with four times the peanut butter and stuffed with a velvety peanut butter filling for an intensely rich, nutty flavor.

$3.50

Raisin Hell Cookie

Soft, chewy oatmeal cookies packed with plump raisins and warm spices, with perfectly crisp edges.

$3.00

Bread(2)

Classic Sourdough Loaf

Our signature sourdough is naturally leavened and cold-proofed for a minimum of 16 hours, allowing time for deep flavor development, improved fermentation, and a beautifully tender crumb. Baked in a loaf pan for a soft, sandwich-friendly shape.


  • Available sliced or unsliced: Choose whole for maximum freshness or sliced for ready-to-enjoy convenience.
  • Shipping is available for select areas. Please message me first if you're interested.

Starting at $10.00

Italian Herb & Cheese Sub Sandwich Bread

Soft, pillowy, and packed with savory flavor, this handcrafted sandwich loaf is baked with a fragrant blend of Italian herbs and topped with a golden layer of melted cheese for a perfectly flavorful crust. The tender interior is light and fluffy, making it ideal for hearty subs, deli sandwiches, garlic bread, or simply enjoying warm with butter. Every bite is rich, cheesy, and bursting with classic Italian herb flavor that turns an ordinary sandwich into something special.

$5.00

Gifts(2)

Sugarbat Gift Basket

A little something sweet, a little something savory, and a whole lot of love!


Whether you’re celebrating a new home, a wedding, an anniversary, a birthday, saying thank you, sending congratulations, or simply spoiling someone who deserves it, the Sugarbat Gift Basket is packed with handmade goodies meant to make any occasion feel a little more special.


Each basket is thoughtfully arranged and gift-ready, featuring a mix of fresh-baked Sugarbat favorites and savory pantry treats.


Each $99 Gift Basket includes:

  • 1 full-size artisan sourdough loaf
  • 2 Italian Herb & Cheese sub loaves
  • 12 delicious, indulgent cookies
  • 1 jar of savory bread-dipping seasoning
  • 1 bottle of extra virgin olive oil
  • 1 bottle of balsamic vinegar
  • A personalized card
  • Gift basket packaging, beautifully arranged and ready to give


Perfect for: • Housewarmings • Weddings & Engagements • Anniversaries • Birthdays • Closing Gifts • Host/Hostess Gifts • Thank-Yous • Congratulations • Client & Employee Gifts • Just Because


Cookie flavors may be selected from currently available flavors. Please email me your personalized gift message and any special requests when ordering at Kate@Sugarbatbakehouse.com


*Because everything from the Bakehouse is made in small batches, advance ordering is recommended for gift baskets.*

$99.00

Sugarbat Giftcard

Give the gift of fresh-baked happiness!

A Sugarbat Bakehouse digital gift card lets your favorite recipient choose exactly what they’re craving, from decadent cookies to artisan sourdough and other small-batch treats. Perfect for birthdays, celebrations, thank-yous, or a little “you deserve something delicious” surprise.

$5.00