Featured Products
Featured Events
About Sweetly Sugared Cookies
📍Lorain/Amherst, Ohio 👶🏼 Mama of 3 👩🏼🍳Licensed Cottage Bakery 🍪Cookies, Cupcakes, Cakepops, Chocolate treats and more
Fulfillment Methods
Open at 10:00 AM
Mon - Sun
9:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Payment Methods
Venmo, Cash App, Zelle/Apple Pay
Policies
50% of total order
5 days
Customer Reviews
Based on 5 reviews
- 08/24/2026
My cookies and cake pops were PHENOMENAL! For my daughters Sweet ONE themed birthday party The designs were perfect 🫶 Everyone was raving about them !
Ordered: Custom Decorated Cookies, Cake Truffles, Cake Pops, Cakesicles
Caitlyn Slaby✔ Verified Order - 08/23/2026
The "Fallout" themed cookies we ordered turned out amazing!! They looked perfect, and tasted even better :)
Ordered: Custom Decorated Cookies
Caitlyn Davidson✔ Verified Order - 08/03/2026
Beautiful cookies and delicious cupcakes! Made exactly to order. This local business deserves 5 stars!
Ordered: Custom Decorated Cookies, Custom Decorated MINI Cookies, +1 more in this review on the reviews page
Annette Wey✔ Verified Order
- Verified Order
- written by customers who ordered through this shop.
- Invited Customer
- written by people the store invited, often customers who bought in person, by message or on another platform; not matched to an order.
- Customer Review
- posted publicly and not matched to an order.
Reviews are shown newest first, whatever their rating, and the average includes every published review.
“Ordered:” under a review of an order names products from that order. The review also appears on the page of each product the customer said it is about; its rating is for the whole order.
A store can hide a review only if it is abusive, spam or advertising, contains personal details, duplicates another review, is not about this store, or was not written by a customer. Fake reviews and reviews written for a reward are not allowed; use Report on the reviews page to flag one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Baked goods are often made with foods that can be known allergens. We do offer gluten free, vegan free, and dye free cookies, cupcakes, and cake pops/truffles. While the kitchen is not nut free, the treats are nut free (unless flavor ordered otherwise.) I strive to do my best to accommodate, but at this point in time, I may not be able to accommodate ALL allergy-conscious orders. Please notify me immediately of any known allergens at any point in time within your order.
I require a minimum of half a dozen cookies for custom orders. (1/2 dozen orders have to be quoted by contacting us.) And a minimum of a dozen cupcakes, cupcakes or gourmet drop cookies.
I understand that ordering cookies (especially different flavors) can make one a little nervous, especially when ordering for a crowd. At this time, we DO offer samples, for purchase at a discounted price. These samples are plain mini circle cookies, with white icing. Cookie samples are sold at 5 mini cookies for $10. After pickup, and within a 1 month period, if you end up placing a custom cookie order of the flavor you sampled, you receive a $10 off coupon for that order! Some flavors may not be available to sample.
Due to the nature of the product, the time it takes to produce, and the customization; I do not offer refunds at this time.
Venmo, Zelle, Cash App, and Apple Cash are accepted. Venmo - @SweetlySugared (last 4 digits of my phone number is 2273) Zelle/Apple Cash - 330-607-2273 Cash App - $sweetlysugaredohio